Our StoryMenuGalleryReviewsFind UsCall to Order
302 E. Bloomington St, Iowa City
Open Daily 4–10 PM
Pizza from the stone hearth
Iowa City — Est. 1957

Pizza Worth
Coming Back
For

Three generations of Pagliai family recipes. Stone hearth ovens. Fresh ingredients, every single day. Iowa City's original pizzeria.

68+ Years
★ 4.5 on Yelp
15 min Carry-Out
Scroll
Since 1957
Award-Winning Pizza
Stone Hearth Ovens
Family Recipes
Fresh Daily
Dine-In & Carry-Out
Iowa City Tradition
Open Daily 4–10 PM
1957
Our Story

Three Generations of Italian Craft

In 1914, John and Katrina Pagliai left Northern Italy for a small mining town in Iowa. They carried little more than memorized family recipes — the crisp doughs, savory sauces, and spiced sausages of their homeland.

By 1957, those recipes had become Iowa City's first pizzeria. Today, we still blend our sausage on-site, simmer our sauce all day, and bake every pie in our original stone hearth ovens. Some things are too good to change.

Explore the Menu →
The Pagliai's kitchen team
The Pagliai's pizza line — handmade, every order
0+
Years Serving Iowa
0
Generations of Recipes
0 min
Carry-Out Ready
0
Stone Hearth Since '57
What People Say
Best pizza in the Midwest. If you live in Iowa City, you already know — but if you're passing through on I-80, stop by. You'll be glad you did.
Tripadvisor Review · Iowa City Visitor
★★★★★

I drove from Arizona just to eat here. By far the best pizza. The homemade sausage is amazing, cheese is perfect, sauce is just right.

Yelp Review
Verified Diner
★★★★★

We've been eating Pagliai's for years and it's a family favorite. We grew up on the Johnston location and now frequent Iowa City.

Tripadvisor Review
Loyal Customer
★★★★★

I've been coming here for over 50 years and little has changed. The Palace Special keeps me coming back every single time.

Tripadvisor Review
50-Year Regular

Hungry Yet?

Call ahead and your pizza is ready in 15 minutes. Dine in at our Northside Marketplace location or grab it on the go. Free parking across the street.

Call to Order — (319) 351-5073
Find Us

Come Say Hello

Address
302 E. Bloomington St
Iowa City, IA 52245
Hours
Open Daily, 4:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Parking
Free parking across the street